o Enforcement Takeaways:
– NYDFS maintains enforcement emphasis on absent/inadequate multi-factor authentication (“MFA”) although its most recent orders have penalized conduct from at least several years ago.
– NYDFS also begins concentrating enforcement on conduct that is the subject of its recent guidance – the September 2024, advisory concerning “Social Engineering of Institutions’ IT Help Desk Personnel,” and its February 2026 NYDFS advisory concerning “Targeted ‘Vishing’ Attacks”.
According to the Rocket Mortgage Consent Order:
o Between December 2019 and August 2021, Rocket Mortgage experienced seven reportable Cybersecurity Events — none of which it reported within the required 72-hour period.
o NYDFS first learned of six of the seven incidents during a routine supervisory examination in October 2021. Rocket Mortgage disclosed the remaining incident during the enforcement investigation some 29 months post-discovery.
o A Microsoft Office 365 migration created a gap in Rocket Mortgage’s MFA controls, permitting unauthorized access to company e-mail accounts.
o Rocket Mortgage also failed to maintain adequate policies/procedures governing secure disposal of nonpublic information (“NPI”) no longer needed for operations.
According to the Mr. Cooper Consent Order:
o Mr. Cooper suffered a significant cybersecurity incident in October 2023 that compromised sensitive information belonging to substantially all of Mr. Cooper’s current and former customers — including hundreds of thousands of New York residents.
o The threat actor gained access to Mr. Cooper’s systems by impersonating an employee and persuading its IT Help Desk to reset an employee’s password. Significantly, the Help Desk employee followed the company’s existing written identity-verification procedures.
o The threat actor exploited exceptions to Mr. Cooper’s MFA controls, obtained access to its network, extracted customer information and deployed ransomware – disrupting online operations for five days.
o NYDFS also found that Mr. Cooper had gone approximately four years without completing a cybersecurity risk assessment.
Both Consent Orders require audits of MFA controls within 90 days.